January is a strange month for many Shopify merchants. The holiday rush is over. Ads feel more expensive and customers slow down. And the big question becomes: how do you keep orders coming in without running another site-wide discount?
This is where 2026 feels different. Shoppers are no longer responding to blanket offers. They expect discounts that make sense for them, based on what they buy, what they browse, and what makes them pause before scrolling away. Personalized discount strategies help increase average order value while protecting margins. With discount apps like DiscountRay, merchants can automate these targeted offers instead of guessing or over-discounting.
Let’s explore 8 personalized new year discount strategies that can help you win, even in a month like January!
In 2026, discounting is no longer about offering the biggest percentage off. It’s about offering the right incentive to the right customer at the right moment. As Shopify stores become more competitive and acquisition costs continue to rise, you can’t afford to rely on broad, one-size-fits-all promotions. Personalization has moved from a nice extra to a core growth requirement.
According to Wisernotify, 80% of customers engage more with brands offering personalized discounts and rewards. When shoppers see discounts that align with their interests, they are far more likely to add extra items instead of checking out with a single product. This naturally increases average order value without forcing merchants to cut deeper into margins.
Personalized discounts also build trust. Customers feel understood rather than pushed. Over time, this leads to higher repeat purchases, stronger loyalty, and more predictable revenue. Instead of chasing volume with aggressive site-wide discounts, merchants can grow AOV by rewarding behavior, intent, and loyalty in smarter, more sustainable ways.
January is not the time for experiments. It’s the time for proven discount strategies that encourage customers to spend a little more without hurting margins. The following new year discount ideas are built around real Shopify problems merchants face after the holidays and how to solve them with smarter, more targeted offers.
One of the biggest January mistakes is running flat discounts that eat margins while shipping costs scare customers away. A $10 shipping fee on a $50 cart often becomes the final reason customers leave.
Tiered discounts solve this quietly. Instead of pushing a single offer, you guide customers upward. “Spend $75 and get free shipping plus 10% off” feels like a reward, not a discount trap. Customers naturally add one more item to reach the threshold.
This works especially well for new visitors who hesitate at checkout. Tools like DiscountRay make it easier to automate these cart-based conditions, but the core idea works anywhere: reward higher spend without discounting every order.
After the holidays, many stores struggle with slow-moving inventory and low AOV from single-item carts. Customers browse, add one product, and leave.
Mix & match bundles change how customers think about value. Instead of pushing one product, you encourage combinations. “Buy any 3 shirts and save 20%” feels flexible and generous. Customers stay in control while naturally building larger carts.
This strategy works best when products complement each other. Apparel, beauty, home goods, and accessories see strong results. You don’t need complex setups. Just clear messaging and visible savings when customers add multiple items.
Most carts miss obvious upsells. Shoes without socks. Skincare without refills. Gym gear without accessories. Generic recommendations often get ignored because they feel random.
Smarter upsells focus on intent. If a customer adds gym gear, offering a small New Year’s discount on protein or accessories feels relevant. The key is timing and context, not the size of the discount.
Some merchants use behavioral data or tools to automate this logic. The principle is simple: show the next logical product and attach a small incentive. Even a 10–15% nudge can significantly increase AOV.
January churn is real. Many holiday buyers disappear because follow-ups feel generic and disconnected from what they actually bought.
Past-purchase discounts bring relevance back. If someone bought a jacket, offering 15% off gloves or accessories makes sense. It feels helpful, not promotional.
This strategy works well through email, SMS, or on-site messages. When discounts are tied to real buying behavior, customers are more likely to return and spend more than they did before. It’s one of the easiest ways to increase repeat AOV without attracting bargain hunters.
Most stores know their top customers matter, but few actively reward them. That’s risky. The top 20% of customers often drive most of the revenue.
VIP discounts don’t need to be flashy. Something as simple as “extra 10% after $200 lifetime spend” makes loyal customers feel seen. It also gives others a reason to spend more to unlock the benefit.
This works for both DTC and B2B stores. Some merchants automate tiers using tools like DiscountRay, while others handle it manually. What matters is consistency. Loyalty-based discounts increase AOV and long-term value without racing to the bottom.
January shoppers hesitate. There’s no holiday deadline, no gifting pressure, and no urgency.
Flash discounts reintroduce momentum. A short window, three hours, one evening, or a single day, pushes customers to act. Pairing the discount with a cart minimum or free gift encourages higher spend instead of rushed small orders.
The key is restraint. Flash discounts work best when limited and clearly communicated. Some merchants use DiscountRay’s scheduling or badges to reinforce urgency. A well-timed email or banner can create a great effect.
Checkout drop-off is one of the quiet AOV killers. Shop Pay converts better than most payment options, yet many stores don’t actively encourage it.
Offering a small incentive for Shop Pay users speeds up checkout and reduces friction. “Pay with Shop Pay and get an extra 10% plus free shipping” feels like a convenience reward, not a discount.
This strategy works especially well on mobile. It doesn’t require deep personalization, just clear messaging at the right moment. Faster checkout often leads to larger carts and fewer abandoned orders.
One-time purchases dominate January, but they rarely build momentum. Subscription offers change that, when done right.
Combining a limited-time discount with a subscription incentive works well. “Flash 15% today plus 20% off your first subscription box” lowers hesitation and creates long-term value.
This strategy works best for consumables like coffee, skincare, supplements, or pet products. Some merchants use tools like DiscountRay alongside Shopify subscriptions to stack conditions, but the real win is mindset: turn a January discount into recurring revenue.
January is your opportunity to rethink how discounts work in your store. As shoppers become more selective, new year discounts need to feel relevant, timely, and intentional. The strategies covered here show that increasing AOV in 2026 doesn’t require deeper cuts. It requires smarter targeting. When discounts align with customer behavior, purchase history, and intent, merchants consistently see stronger cart values and healthier margins. These 2026 discount strategies can turn a slow start into a strong Q1 and set the tone for the rest of the year. Tools like DiscountRay help automate this process, but the real impact comes from applying the right strategy at the right time.
Ready to reset and dominate Q1? Start testing today and watch your AOV climb.
Yes, when done strategically. New year discounts that are personalized or tied to cart value, bundles, or loyalty tend to increase AOV more effectively than flat, site-wide offers.
Personalized discounts feel relevant to shoppers. Instead of discounting every order, you reward specific behavior, which helps increase average order value while protecting profit margins.
Merchants can use tiered discounts, bundles, free shipping thresholds, and targeted incentives to encourage customers to add more items instead of lowering prices across the store.
Get started with our free plan or unlock premium features with a 14-day free trial.
30-day money-back guarantee!
English 
日本語 
Français 
Deutsch 
Español 
简体中文 
Italiano